During the Fenian Raids, Fort Erie had been in ruins and disrepair for some time. The capture of this fort was more symbolic than a strategic military point for the Fenians, and this point often gets lost on many readers of these accounts. Fort Erie certainly did not look as it appears today.
One Hackensack NJ newspaper reporting on the Fenian Raids at the time gave an interesting perspective for North Jersey readers to understand what Fort Erie would have looked like. The reporter compared it to “Fort Lee” in Bergen County, meaning it was not much of a fort, with defensive walls, at all.
“THE FENIANS ON THE WAR PATH – On Thursday night of last week, an armed body of Fenians crossed from Buffalo to a place called “Fort Erie” on the Canada side and captured it, with all it’s in habitants – of which there were none however. “Fort Erie”, it appears is about as much a “Fort” as our own Fort Lee. The place is named for the old Fort Erie of the War of 1812, which had been long dismantled and unoccupied. – The Bergen County Democrat and New Jersey State Register of Hackensack NJ of June 8th, 1866″